Mobile Version: mobile.leaderherald.com
RSS:
Gloversville Weather Forecast, NY
Member Login: Email: Password:
Search: Local News Classified Web
Local News  In Brief  Business  Editorials  Obituaries  Local Sports  Welcome-Home  Blogs  CU Galleries  Local Classifieds  Jobs

Arrests made in Glove Theatre theft

Son of City Court judge among those charged

By RODNEY MINOR, The Leader-Herald
POSTED: July 17, 2008

GLOVERSVILLE - The son of City Court Judge Vincent DeSantis was one of three men arrested Wednesday by city police for allegedly breaking into the Glove Theatre and stealing about $14,000 worth of tools and equipment.

James C. DeSantis, 20, of 23 Prospect Ave., was charged with third-degree burglary and third-degree grand larceny, both felonies. Police leveled the same charges against Corey A. Wollard, 17, and Shawn Hemstreet, 16, both of 33 Sixth Ave.

As of this morning, police still were looking for a fourth person who they believe was involved in the burglary.

Police reported more than $7,000 in power tools were stolen. The tools belonged to Randall Etheredge, a carpenter from Ancram, Columbia County, who volunteered last year to help renovate the stage at the theater. He eventually joined the Glove's Board of Directors.

A number of other items also were reportedly taken from the theater, including two sound boards, six walkie-talkies, a number of hand-held and wireless microphones and some candy that was to be sold at the concession stand.

Police Capt. Jim Lorenzoni said "good, old-fashioned police work" led to the arrests. Detectives conducted a large number of interviews before the arrests were made, he said.

Police said some items have been recovered, including the soundboards. They were found at the residence of Wollard and Hemstreet, police said.

Police said detectives are investigating the whereabouts of other stolen items.

Emily Grant, executive director of the theater, said after the burglary occurred that given the location of some of the items, it seemed as if someone with knowledge of the theater must have taken them.

Lorenzoni said it was possible, though it has not been confirmed by police, James DeSantis could have been familiar with the layout of the theater through his family's participation in its activities.

A former president of the Glove's Board of Directors, Vincent DeSantis was a key player in getting the theater reopened in 1997. It had been closed for more than 20 years.

Vincent DeSantis, who has been serving on the bench in Fulton County Family Court, said this morning it would be improper for him to comment on the arrests at this time.

The three suspects were arraigned Wednesday night in City Court and remanded to the Fulton County Jail in lieu of $10,000 bail. Jail officials said all three still were there this morning.

Member Comments
View Comments: | 1-25 |26-50 |51-75 |76-81 | Post a comment
RageoftheDay
07-17-08 1:21 PM
Mr R I hear ya and I know life is not fair nor do I think it ever will be. Just would like to stive for fair and equal treatment. There are also rights in the consitution taht project the innocent until proven guilty, the right to be judged by your peers etc etc. I know Rdney was just doing his job. I guess that's why I would not be a good reporter. Maybe it's our fault we buy it therefore they sell it. And I'm not speaking of the LH here, mostly the mainstream media. I actually think that the LH does a good and fair job.

MrRoboto
07-17-08 1:15 PM
Nah. I'll still take American-style First Amendment protections, Floridian. The pros far outweight the cons.

In Canada, a journalist named Mark Steyn is being pursued by "human rights commissions" that want to punish him for writing less-than-kind words about Islam.

I'd prefer journalists self-censored on stuff like this. But, bringing the weight of government down on them is medicine far worse than the ailment.

Floridian
07-17-08 1:12 PM
and Mr.Roboto..in Canada as well England, there is freedom of speech, but in the case of judicial items pending, these countries are not allowed to publish anything about a crime until after the verdict is decided in order to not sway the jury pool; maybe not a bad idea...?

Floridian
07-17-08 1:10 PM
Good for everyone involved in working on this situation and also GREAT for the production company that stated that the show will go on....

DuVall
07-17-08 12:42 PM
I don't know all the facts regarding these young men but I do know that the hardest lesson to teach young people - even adults struggle with this one - is that Choices have consequences. Many people don't think past the actual doing of an act and how lives can be changed in an instant. Don't judge the Judge; judge the perpetrators.

MrRoboto
07-17-08 12:38 PM
Frankly, in an ideal world, we wouldn't publish accusations at all.

But, the First Amendment allows the media to report anything, with virtually no restrictions. Except for libel laws--which, incidentally, put all the burden of proof on the shoulders of the person whose reputation is jeopardized--there is almost no check on the media.

And, "not guilty" verdicts and dismissals rarely get as much space as charges--if any space at all.

It's not a fair world. In a fair world, there would be no blotters, and we'd only report on cases when a verdict was rendered.

But it's not a fair world, and I think Rodney and his editors were just doing their job on this one.

Still, I feel bad for Judge D. I'd imagine the man feels some anguish today.

JUSTME2008
07-17-08 12:36 PM
Okay ... I see the point and I agree, If LH published one parents name "all" should have been published. It just shouldn't matter who you are. I know the bigger names get the headlines/spot light! Doesn't make it right.

Silent
07-17-08 12:35 PM
Justme, Who is "WE" The people from Gloversville? Johnstown, or ??? This artical is in alot of papers, not only the LH - Serch for one of the names, and you will see others. That is why we feel the Judge should not have been the only one pointed out.

MrRoboto
07-17-08 12:32 PM
Were that it was so, Rage. But, consider the case of the Bush twins.

A few years back, Jenna and Barbara Bush--the daughters of the President and First Lady--were out at Chuy's, a college bar in Austin, TX, under-age. Jenna was a student at UT-Austin, and Barbara was a student at Yale.

They were doing something millions of college students do every night--or at least every weekend. They were drinking under-age.

And they got arrested. (No doubt, someone recognized them and knew of their age--and decided to get political payback by hurting the President's kids.)

This made national news. Should it have?

The "crime" itself was a fairly pedestrian one. Given that few college students in America don't drink under-age, it's hard to say it reflects in any way on their upbringing.

But, by the rules of journalism, it merited a story.

Ditto in this instance.

RageoftheDay
07-17-08 12:30 PM
No...your name wouldn't be in the paper unless you were well know. The parents of the other 2 were not mentioned by name. All I say is be FAIR! If for one do it for all.

JUSTME2008
07-17-08 12:28 PM
It's the judges son... what does it really matter if names were mentioned or not??? We would know anyhow ... I don't see the big deal.

Anyone's child can get into trouble, doesn't warrant to hide name because of a position held. If it were our kids our names would be published why shouldn't his?

RageoftheDay
07-17-08 12:24 PM
Mr. R - Don't disagree with this is waht sells papers and the way journalism is practiced. It would have been different if Judge D committed the crime. He didn't. If one parents name goes in they all go in. And who says the way journalism has been practice and taught has been right? It should be fair and balancec, like Fox News (ha! That was sarcasm) Let's change the way to do business. Leave the innocent out of it. This is starting to stick in my craw.

MrRoboto
07-17-08 12:20 PM
Agreed there, Silent. And, let's hope that the preponderance of evidence weighs on these kids' side...because this is a really awful way to screw up a life at a fairly young age.

Silent
07-17-08 12:20 PM
MR. R. I guess your right on this point. I have knowen Judge D. for many years, and his child. Mr. D put alot of effort into raising his child - Just goes to show, kids will be who they are, no matter where they started from.

Silent
07-17-08 12:12 PM
Suzie, I would have to disagree with you on that one. I can't say he has never been in trouble but I also know that he has a job. Does volunteer work and some other things. I don't see anyone on here saying he did not do anything wrong. Though I did say innocent until proven guilty, but I thought that was for all of us. Let’s not smear a person just because we don't like him.

SUZIE101
07-17-08 12:07 PM
The Hemstreet kid is nothing but trouble, has been since he moved into the neighborhood. It was only a matter of time he got caught. Can't speak for the others, don't know anything about them. It's a case of, my kid can't do anything wrong, it's always someone else's fault!

MrRoboto
07-17-08 12:06 PM
Unfortunately, Silent, society's standard on what constitutes a minor has shifted a bit. While it's true that one attains their majority at 18, and attains the ability to consent at 17, in an era where attending college is now the norm, the actions of people into their early 20s tend to reflect on their parents.

And, given Judge D's prominence--he IS, after all, a public figure and one charged with dishing out punishment to lawbreakers--when his son, all of 20 years old, breaks into a prominent city landmark and steals a few thousand bucks worth of stuff, well, the news story writes itself.

To not write it this way would have been journalist malpractice--and, as IKnooow noted, would have led to charges of favoritism for a popular public official.

IKnooow
07-17-08 12:03 PM
And if the paper wanted to "get headlines" they would have put it in the headline, not the lead paragraph.

IKnooow
07-17-08 12:02 PM
You're right MrRoboto. It's a good lead. Written any other way and people would have asked why the name of the son of a prominent citizen was buried in the story. That's the big news in this story.

Silent
07-17-08 12:01 PM
MR.R the Judge neither broke his arm, or in this case was involved with any of this, his Child, was over the age of 18. His child did not live at his house, the only reason it was written like this was to get headlines, let’s find a missing laptop and brief case instead.

MrRoboto
07-17-08 11:54 AM
OK, guys, you know I've never been a fan of Rodney's, um, writing style. But, I'm gonna defend him on this one.

Waaayyyyy back in my college days, I remember taking a journalism course for kicks. One of the first lessons was on what makes a news story newsworthy. I googled around, and that list is still out there:

ww w.mediacollege.co m/journalism/news/newsworthy.html

Note one of the five factors is "prominence."

Rodney kind of had to write the lead that way.

SNOWGRINCH
07-17-08 11:47 AM
Thanks GPD!

Silent
07-17-08 11:41 AM
They say there looking for the 4th, yet they already know his location. If they only would put such an effort into the other problems in Gloversville, as in this case, there would be less of these cases - They will make an example of these kids, it’s a shame, so young. Also lets point out it’s a judges son, as if he is different then any other child - There where 4 of them, all innocent until proven guilty, Not that this article would prove it. I also know the parents of the Hemstreets, Not a bad home either. and your right R.O.D - Its not the parents that did it. Leave the judge out of it.

FREEDOM
07-17-08 11:39 AM
I agree rage the judges name should have never been brought up he didnt do the crime whats wrong with this newspaper, One of the few people who actually does something for the city gets his name smeared for no reason. The LH should be ashamed.

JUSTME2008
07-17-08 11:39 AM
Kudos to the police dept! I am thrilled that thieves were caught!

Goes to show you that it dosen't matter who your parents are...all kids can be very stupid! Hopefully this teach them a lesson and "learn" from it.

You must first login before you can comment.
Existing Member Login
Not a Member?
Create a Member Account  
*Your email address:
*Password:
    Forgot Password?
  Remember my email address.
Local News  In Brief  Business  Editorials  Obituaries  Local Sports  Welcome-Home  Blogs  CU Galleries  Local Classifieds  Jobs